Insurance Defense

The experienced litigators at Barrett McNagny have earned a reputation for providing high-quality and efficient representation to national, regional, and specialized insurance companies. Our attorneys have extensive experience in handling a wide range of insurance defense matters, including auto and home claims, personal injury, property damage, premises liability, coverage disputes, and bad faith. We also work with insurers on medical malpractice and worker’s compensation claims, intellectual property issues, and professional liability matters.

At both the trial and appellate levels, the attorneys comprising Barrett’s insurance defense group have handled thousands of cases with many favorable verdicts and judgments and numerous reported decisions in the State and Federal courts Whether a case proceeds through an alternative dispute resolution mechanism such as mediation or arbitration or whether it goes to trial before a judge or jury (and potentially to an appellate court,) our litigators are prepared to defend insured individuals and insurance companies in any forum.

Our Approach

Our attorneys work alongside an experienced paralegal team, whose members are skilled and efficient in handling insurance defense and coverage dispute cases. We understand that it is important to be able to contact someone when issues arise, and our team is committed to providing clients with a result-driven approach through professional service and communication.

For over 75 years Barrett McNagny has been listed by the A.M. Best Company as a “Client Recommended Insurance Attorney,” and our attorneys are members of a variety of organizations specific to the litigation area, including the Defense Research Institute and the Defense Trial Counsel of Indiana. Among our litigators are two Fellows in the America College of Trial Lawyers and partners in our insurance defense practice group who have spoken at state, national, and international seminars.

Listing of Our Insurance Clients:

• ACE Westchester Specialty Group
• Admiral Insurance Company
• Aetna Insurance Company
• Aetna Life and Casualty Company
• AIG
• Allied Group Insurance
• Allstate Insurance Company
• American Home Insurance Company
• American Specialty Insurance & Risk Services, Inc.
• Auto-Owners Insurance Company
• Canal Insurance Company
• Celina Group
• Central Mutual Insurance Company
• Cherokee Guarantee Company Inc a RRG
• Chicago Motor Club Insurance Company
• Church Mutual Insurance Company
• Cincinnati Insurance Co.
• Cincinnati Insurance Company
• Citizens Insurance Company of America
• CNA Insurance Company
• Disability Insurance Specialists, LLC
• EMC Insurance Company
• EMPAC RRG
• Erie Insurance Company
• Everest National Insurance Company
• Farm Bureau Insurance Company
• Farmers Insurance Group
• Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
• Foremost Insurance Company
• Fort Wayne Medical Surety Company RRG
• Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Company
• GEICO
• Government Employees Insurance Company
• GRE Insurance Group
• The Hanover Insurance Company
• Harco National Insurance Company
• The Hartford Insurance Group
• Hastings Mutual Insurance Company
• Illinois Casualty Company
• Indiana Farm Bureau
• Indiana Insurance Company
• Indiana Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Company
• Indiana University Health Risk Retention Group
• Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club
• Interstate Assurance Company
• K & K Insurance Group, Inc.
• Lancer Insurance Company
• Lincoln National Life Insurance Company
• Madison National Life Insurance Company, Inc.
• Markel Southwest
• The Medical Protective Company
• MetLife Auto & Home
• Metropolitan Insurance Company
• MMIC Group
• National Interstate Insurance Company
• Nationwide Insurance
• Nautilus Insurance Company
• OccuSure Workers' Compensation Specialist
• Pafco General Insurance Company
• Pekin Insurance Company
• Philadelphia Insurance Companies
• ProAssurance Corporation
• Progressive Casualty Insurance Company
• Prudential Insurance Company of America
• Prudential Property and Casualty Insurance Company
• Reliant American Insurance Company
• Sagamore Insurance Company
• Selective Insurance Company of America
• Sentry Insurance a Mutual Company
• Shelter Mutual Insurance Company
• Standard Security Life Insurance Company of New York
• State Auto Insurance Company
• State Farm Fire and Casualty Company
• State Farm Insurance Company
• Trident Insurance
• United National Group
• United States Liability Insurance
• Unitrin Property and Casualty Insurance Group
• Westfield Companies
• Zurich Insurance Company

Lead Counsel for

• Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company

Contact Our Team

Contact a member of our Litigation team by clicking on their picture below.